Abortion and Counselling

I wholeheartedly agree that ultimately it is the woman’s right to choose whether to terminate her pregnancy and whether to seek counselling beforehand.   However, there is disturbing evidence of biased pre-abortion counselling advice (from both camps) – see this undercover story. Do read it.

The Dorries/Field amendments to the Health & Social Care Bill do not propose compulsory pre-abortion counselling, but seek to remove any counselling role from organisations who currently provide a time-saving “one-stop shop” service – from advice to medical assessment to abortion procedure.  Human nature being what it is, people seek the path of least resistance and a “one-stop shop” is often the easiest path to take.

These organisations have a financial interest as they are paid per abortion.  People say they are charities or “not for profit” organisations so they are not profit-driven.  However it cannot have escaped anybody’s notice that organisations like BPAS & Marie Stopes are run like businesses with marketing departments, large budgets and they have hundreds of jobs, from the well-paid CEO downwards, which depend primarily on the income stream from abortions. The same can be said for some of the large pro-life groups which offer pre-abortion counselling.

Worryingly, the Dorries/Field amendments do not stipulate that the counselling should be *impartial*.  Indeed there will be no restrictions on who can provide the service – indeed any pro-life, pro-choice or neutral groups can do so – as long as they do not perform abortions and are able to meet guidelines (currently set by the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists, but may change to NICE under the amendments)

Will this create a messy “free for all” market? Will it become even more confusing and stressful for women who are already under tremendous emotional strain?  It is probable.

So how can we try to ensure that if a woman does want counselling, she has expedited access to an independent service which is impartial, free, expedient, supportive & readily available?

Why not offer such a service (within RCOG guidelines) on, or paid for by the NHS, staffed by public & private sector counsellors who are full & appropriately qualified members of the British Association for Counselling and Psychotherapy (BACP), who have no interest in whether a woman has the abortion eventually and whose sole aim is to help the woman by giving support and counselling.

Just a thought.

PS. I am not in either the pro-life or pro-choice camp, I am a man so I don’t presume to know what a woman feels or thinks, least of all second guess what is best for her. Mine is only a suggestion for an alternative, or an addition to what is available.

Advertisements

About Art Li

Briefly, I am a lawyer, keen amateur photographer, dog lover and politics junkie but not a member of any party. Full details on Biography page. Follow me on Twitter @Art_Li.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Abortion and Counselling

  1. When you have s monopoly provider or arbiter, it risks not only being “partial”, but skewed in one direction.

    • Art Li says:

      Thank you for commenting and I take your point about the risks, hence I suggested the involvement of British Association for Counselling and Psychotherapy (BACP) which says “it is essential that pre-abortion counselling is freely available, independent, unbiased and ethical. And counsellors should never give advice, pressuring a client to a particular course of action is fundamentally unethical and a contradiction of our profession”.

  2. Fat Jac says:

    I imagine it is hard to find truly partial people to work in this area. It is a very emotive topic. likely only to attract people with an interest,

    • Art Li says:

      Fair point. I think it is a case of having to put trust in medics and counsellors to not let their personal views and feelings come out… Easier said than done of course but we can’t extract someone’s beliefs & values before they go through the office door.

    • Exactly right.

      But some advice, from what ever ‘side’, is better than none at all… which is what girls often receive at the moment.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s